When marcion selected luke's gospel did he have opinions about other gospels?

Bill Russel asked a question: When marcion selected luke's gospel did he have opinions about other gospels?
Asked By: Bill Russel
Date created: Tue, Aug 17, 2021 2:49 AM
Date updated: Wed, Jan 26, 2022 6:11 PM



Those who are looking for an answer to the question «When marcion selected luke's gospel did he have opinions about other gospels?» often ask the following questions:

❔ When was lukes gospel written?

  • The Gospel of Luke was written around A.D. 60. The Gospel of Luke was written to Theophilus, meaning "the one who loves God." Historians are not sure who this Theophilus (mentioned in Luke 1:3) was, although most likely, he was a Roman with an intense interest in the newly forming Christian religion.

❔ Who used mark's gospel when writing other gospels?

AnswerIt is known that the authors of Mathew's Gospel and Luke's Gospel relied on Mark's Gospel for their information about the life and mission of Jesus. Whenever they agree with Mark, the text is almost identical in the Greek language. Also, the "Missing Block" proves that the author of Luke knew nothing about Jesus apart from what he found in Mark. Both Matthew and Luke also relied on a hypothetical 'Q' document, also written in Greek, for many of the sayings and parables attributed to Jesus.The link between John's Gospel and Mark is less direct. The author of this Gospel drew mainly from Luke's Gospel, often changing or reversing material form Luke, thus relying indirectly on Mark's Gospel. He also used some material directly from Mark, so both gospels must have been known to him.

❔ Did gospel john read other gospels?

What is missing from John's Gospel?

  • John’s Gospel is missing the Olivet Discourse, the Biblical passage (found in all the other gospels: Matthew 24, Mark 13, and Luke 21) in which Jesus predicts the destruction of the Temple.

1 other answer

Marcion selected the Gospel According to St Luke and amended it to remove references to the Old Testament. He likely chose Luke's Gospel because of its compassion for the poor. It is also thought that he did not know of John's Gospel, as that had probably only been written quite recently and did not yet enjoy a wide circulation. In any case, John's Gospel with its focus on wealthy and important individuals, would probably not have suited his needs.

Your Answer

We've handpicked 22 related questions for you, similar to «When marcion selected luke's gospel did he have opinions about other gospels?» so you can surely find the answer!

How is john's gospel different from the other gospels?

The Gospel According to St John differs to such an extent from the synoptic gospels (Matthew, Mark and Luke) that Origen felt obliged to defend ithe Gospel, saying, "Although he does not always tell the truth literally, he always tells it spiritually" (Origen, Commentary on John). The synoptic gospels regarded Jesus as the Son of God, but not pre-existing and divine. John is quite clear, from verse 1, that Jesus was with God in the beginning. Matthew and Luke, in the two different nativity accounts, say that Jesus was born in Bethlehem, whereas John appears to say that he was not. In the synoptics, Jesus overturns the moneychanger's tables at the end of his ministry, as a prelude to his arrest, but John places this event at the beginning of his ministry.To explain the above differences and many others that can be found between John and the synoptic gospels, it needs to be understood that all the New Testament gospels were originally anonymous and were only attributed to the apostles whose names they now bear later in the second century. Biblical scholars say there is no good reason to accept those attributions, and that the author of John could not have been an eyewitness to the events he described. It is now recognised that John's Gospel is loosely based on Luke's Gospel and, to a lesser extent, Mark's Gospel. Luke was in turn derived from Mark and the hypothetical 'Q' document.Another Answer:Though there are many who would 'interpret' John's Gospel in various ways, the simple answer to your question is best given in the Scripture from the Gospel of John:John 20:31New King James Version (NKJV) 31 but these are written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in His name.Unlike the three other Gospels, John clearly and succinctly states its purpose - how an individual can find eternal life.A close read of this Gospel will reveal several verses of clues to the authorship of the work. Upon weighing each it is reasonable to conclude that this book was written by the Apostle John. This was the consensus of the early Christians such as Polycarp (AD 60-155), who was a follower of John.

How is mark's gospel different from the other gospels?
  • First it is significantly shorter than the other Gospels–with only 16 chapters compared to Matthew (28), Luke (24) and John (21). But more important is how Mark begins his Gospel and how he ends it. He has no account of the virgin birth of Jesus–or for that matter, any birth of Jesus at all.
Why is luke's gospel different from the other gospels?
  • Luke's gospel is a product of a kind of Pauline Christianity. And so it tells the story in some slightly different ways than do the other gospels. It has different interests.
What is the gospel of marcion called today?
  • The Gospel of Marcion, called by its adherents the Gospel of the Lord, was a text used by the mid-2nd-century Christian teacher Marcion of Sinope to the exclusion of the other gospels. The majority of scholars agree the gospel was an edited version of the Gospel of Luke.
Are there other gospels which give us more details about jesus?
  • Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John were the 4 which hit all 5 of these criteria, so they were included. Now, this probably makes you wonder, are there other gospels which we could read today which would give us more details on Jesus? Short answer is not really. Long answer is maybe.
Did matthew's gospel come from one of the other gospels?

Yes. When laid alongside Mark's Gospel and viewed synoptically ('with the same eye') in the original Greek language, it can be seen that Matthew's Gospel contains some 80 pe cent of Mark. It also contains a smaller amount of material from the hypothetical 'Q' Gospel. Scholars do not know the source for some material unique to Matthew, but say that much of it could not be historial.

How does the gospel of john compare to other gospels?
  • So, compared to any other gospel, John's Gospel has around twice as many references to Jesus as either King of the Jews or as Son of God, but the real emphasis is on Jesus' divinity. (*) Some early manuscripts, including Sinaiticus, omit 'Son of God' in Mark 1:1, so there is no certainty that the phrase is original to Mark's Gospel.
How is john's gospel different from the other three gospels?
  • John's Gospel is rather different from the other three. Whether or not he knew them (or any one of them) continues to be debated. In any event, his witness to Jesus goes its own way, highlighting matters that in the other Gospels remain implicit and underdeveloped.
How is the gospel of mark different from other gospels?
  • Mark ’s Gospel also has a somewhat rougher, less literary style than its peers. It is not nearly as elegant as Luke, for example, nor as thematically structured as Matthew. Mark also has a greater number of “problem passages,” difficult statements and actions by Jesus that Matthew and Luke tend to smooth out.
What makes the gospel of matthew different from other gospels?
  • In addition to materials found in the Gospel of Mark, the Gospel of Matthew contains a large number of Jesus' sayings and discourses and also a group of stories not found in any of the other Gospels.
Is q a source of lukes gospel?

Most modern scholars agree that the main sources used for Luke were (a) the Gospel of Mark, (b) a hypothetical sayings collection called the Q source, and (c) material found in no other gospels, often referred to as the L (for Luke) source.

What are some prayers in lukes gospel?

What do you pray for in Luke 1?

  • Praying through Luke 1:4 Heavenly Father, thank You for the good news of the gospel of Christ and for our Salvation which is ours by grace through faith in Jesus Christ our Lord. Thank You for the truth of Your Word and for the wonderful message of grace that is extended to all who trust in Christ for Salvation.
Who visits the jesus in lukes gospel?

Where did Jesus visit in the Book of Luke?

  • Jesus heals ten men on the border between Samaria and Galilee (Luke 17:11-19). 17. Jesus heals a blind beggar near Jericho (Luke 18:35-43). 18. Jesus visits and speaks to Zacchaeus in Jericho (Luke 19:1-9).
What other gospels are there?
  • Now, from early on, of course, we have the four main gospels that we now see in the New Testament; Matthew, Mark, Luke , and John , but there were many others that we know existed. There's the Gospel of Peter and the Gospel of Thomas, each of which may go back to a very early tradition.
Who wrote the other gospels?

That depends. What do you mean by "other?" The four gospels were written by the Apostle Matthew, John Mark, who received much of his account from the Apostle Peter, Luke, who served as a doctor and followed Jesus, and John the Revelator, who replaced every mention of his name with "The disciple whom Jesus loved." There are a few other gospels, for example in the Catholic Bible, there's a gospel that Thomas (the Doubter) wrote.

Why do the gospels have different stories from each other?

Because every Gospel is written from a different point of view and from a different Religion.

How does the gospel of john differ from the other gospels?
  • 1. John focuses on our life in Jesus While the other gospels emphasize the Kingdom of God and the Kingdom of Heaven, John instead emphasizes new life found in Jesus. It’s from John that we get Christ’s famous claim: “I am the way, and the truth and the life.
How does the gospel of john relate to the other gospels?
  • Now the Gospel of John has some relationships to the sources used by the other gospels.... The passion narrative in John is essentially the same as the passion narrative in Mark, Matthew, Luke and in the Gospel of Peter. The other thing that is common with the other gospels is a chain of miracle stories....
How does the gospel of mark compare to the other gospels?
  • In relation to the other gospels, Mark makes Jesus look like a Marvel superhero. Mark doesn't focus on dialogue nearly as much as he focuses on Christ's actions. This is seen in the way Mark uses the Greek word "euthus" typically translated as "immediately."
How does the gospel of matthew differ from the other gospels?
  • The Gospel of Matthew mainly differs from the other gospels due to its heavily Jewish perspective. He also quotes the Old Testament far more than any of the other gospels. He spends a great deal of time pointing out references from the Torah present in Jesus' teachings.
How is the gospel of john different from the other gospels?
  • Most of you know that we are nearing the end of our study through the Gospel of John. We have seen that John’s Gospel is different from Matthew, Mark and Luke (the Synoptic Gospels) in many places. One of the unique features of John’s Gospel is his account of Jesus’ last supper or Passover with His disciples.
How is the gospel of luke different from the other gospels?
  • Luke is very unique from these. Luke focuses and records the last year of Jesus’s ministry in detail while Jesus traveled from Galilee to Judea, and you can find that last year in Luke from chapters 9–19. The Gospel of John is amazing. John focuses on Jesus’s ministry in Judea.